Full Color Custom Butt Plug SALE at Sinful O

Full Color Custom Butt Plugs83 Products

Now, butt plugs available in Full Color!
  • 12
  • 16
  • 32
  • all
Category
  • $10 & Under Toys (144)
  • $20 & Under Toys (259)
  • 2 for $50 Sale (0)
  • 2 for $50 Vibe & Glass Sale (0)
  • 50% OFF Butt Plugs (68)
  • Accessories (57)
  • Acrylic Canes (12)
  • Anal Beads (12)
  • Anal Hooks and Bondage Plugs (16)
  • Anal Training Toys (54)
  • B*tch Custom Butt Plugs (10)
  • Bamboo & Rattan Canes (6)
  • BDSM Spanking Paddles (137)
  • Beginner Butt Plugs (58)
  • Best Selling Products (1381)
  • Black Friday at The Kink Factory (122)
  • Black Tail Butt Plug (27)
  • Blindfolds (10)
  • Blonde Tail Butt Plugs (5)
  • Blue Tail Butt Plug (12)
  • Bondage Gear (168)
  • Boy or Boi Custom Butt Plugs (3)
  • Brat Custom Butt Plugs (5)
  • Brown Tail Butt Plugs (17)
  • Bunny Tail Butt Plugs (14)
  • Butt Bruisers (20)
  • Butt Plug of the Month (4)
  • Butt Plugs (209)
  • Butt Plugs and Anal Toys (585)
  • Buy 1 Get 1 50% OFF (207)
  • Buy More and Save! (71)
  • CBT Toys (19)
  • Chastity Cages (25)
  • Clearance and Overstock (90)
  • Closet Collection (5)
  • Cock Custom Butt Plugs (28)
  • Collars and Leashes (34)
  • Crops (12)
  • Cum Custom Butt Plugs (20)
  • Custom Butt Plugs (258)
  • Custom Butt Plugs - Long (28)
  • Custom Butt Plugs Advanced (37)
  • Custom Butt Plugs for Beginners (39)
  • Custom Butt Plugs Intermediate (38)
  • Custom Butt Plugs with Images (85)
  • Custom Butt Plugs with Words (227)
  • Custom Canes (12)
  • Custom Locks (35)
  • Custom Paddles and Butt Plugs (16)
  • Custom Pendants (17)
  • Cyber Monday (56)
  • Daddy's Collection (89)
  • Daddy's Custom Butt Plugs (51)
  • Delrin and Lexan Canes (9)
  • Designer Spanking Paddles (21)
  • Dildos and Vaginal Toys (91)
  • Easy to Clean Toys (66)
  • Emoji Impression Paddles (6)
  • Enema Kits (2)
  • Engraved Spanking Paddles (69)
  • Extra Large Anal Toys and Butt Plugs (28)
  • Extra Long Pony Tails (7)
  • F*ck Toy Custom Butt Plugs (7)
  • Faux Fur Tail Butt Plugs (25)
  • FemDom Products (89)
  • Flash Sale (25)
  • Floggers (18)
  • Focus Paddles (5)
  • Fraternity Spanking Paddles (7)
  • Friday ONLY SITC Special (13)
  • Full Color Custom Butt Plugs (83)
  • Gags (18)
  • Geeky Custom Butt Plugs (30)
  • Gift Cards (6)
  • Girl or Gurl Custom Butt Plugs (16)
  • Glass Butt Plugs (19)
  • Glass Dildos (23)
  • Glass Sex Toys (44)
  • Heavy Butt Plugs (9)
  • Heavy Hitting Impact Toys (46)
  • High Impact, Low Effort Toys (28)
  • Holiday Gift Giving Guide (100)
  • Impression Spanking Paddles with Images (31)
  • Impression Spanking Paddles with Words (31)
  • Jelly Butt Plugs & Dildos (12)
  • Jewel Butt Plugs (59)
  • Just for Fun Novelty Items (35)
  • Kegel Balls and Anal Beads (11)
  • Kitty Custom Butt Plugs (29)
  • Large Discipline Spanking Paddles (24)
  • Last Minute Gift Ideas (63)
  • Leather Restraints (18)
  • Leather Spanking Paddles (4)
  • Limited Plug Packages (7)
  • Master's Custom Butt Plugs (38)
  • Medical Play Toys (4)
  • Metal Butt Plugs (154)
  • Mommy's Custom Butt Plugs (1)
  • Natural Color Pony Tails (16)
  • New Arrivals (116)
  • Newest Products (1375)
  • Nipple Play Toys (28)
  • Ombre Pony Tails (23)
  • OTK Spanking Paddles (30)
  • Penis Plugs (18)
  • Personal Lubricants (22)
  • Pet Custom Butt Plugs (3)
  • Pink Tail Butt Plug (10)
  • Pocket Toys (7)
  • Pony Tail Butt Plugs (44)
  • Pre-made Fox Tail Butt Plug Sale (0)
  • Princess Custom Butt Plugs (8)
  • Prostate Stimulation Toys (34)
  • Purple Tail Butt Plug (10)
  • PVC Restraints (11)
  • Real Fur Animal Tail Butt Plugs (114)
  • Realistic Dildos (20)
  • Red Tail Butt Plug (6)
  • Restraints (65)
  • Rubber Batons (5)
  • Rug Beaters (6)
  • Sale Items (87)
  • Select Jewel Butt Plugs (24)
  • Sensation Toys (13)
  • Silicone Butt Plugs (37)
  • Silicone Dildos (15)
  • Sin Box - BDSM Mystery Boxes (3)
  • Sissy Custom Butt Plugs (2)
  • Slave Custom Butt Plugs (9)
  • Slut Custom Butt Plugs (49)
  • Solid Color Pony Tails (17)
  • Spanking Canes & Crops (48)
  • Spanking Paddles (69)
  • Spanking Paddles All (163)
  • Spencer Spanking Paddles (4)
  • Spring Butt Plug SALE! (47)
  • Steel Dildos (8)
  • Steel Impact Toys (6)
  • Steel Restraints (19)
  • Stocking Stuffers (414)
  • Strap-On Dildos (24)
  • Strap-On Play (59)
  • Synthetic Spanking Paddles (11)
  • Tails for Detachable Plugs (0)
  • Tenderizer Spanking Paddles (5)
  • Thuddy Spanking Paddles (15)
  • Titanium and Carbon Fiber (2)
  • Unique Canes (19)
  • Unique Impact Toys (33)
  • Urethral Sounds (10)
  • Valentine's Day Specials (313)
  • Vegan Friendly Impact Toys (21)
  • Vegan Friendly Restraints (35)
  • Vegan Friendly Tail Butt Plugs (34)
  • Vibrators (32)
  • Wands & Attachments (48)
  • Water Based Lubricants (7)
  • Whimsical Pony Tails (22)
  • Whips by Roger Patterson (9)
  • Whips for Beginners (4)
  • White Tail Butt Plug (2)
  • Whore Custom Butt Plugs (19)
  • Yellow Tail Butt Plug (4)
Custom Hero Butt Plug Small Choose Your Image 1-10
Custom Hero Butt Plug Small Choose Your Image 1-10
$ 34.99
Everyone has a favorite hero.  Choose yours!  This item is made to order.  Please allow 1-2 business days for production prior to shipping.  All Orders Ship Discreetly! Style 1: Insertable length: 2.4 inchesDiameter at widest point: 1.1 inchesStyle 2: Insertable length: 2.4 inchesDiameter at widest point: 1.1 inchesStyle 3:Insertable length: 2.5 inchesDiameter...
Options Quick look
Daddy's Little Slut Butt Plug
Daddy's Little Slut Butt Plug
$ 34.99
Pink Daddy's Little Slut butt plug.  Choose the size of your plug and enjoy the sensation of nice heavy butt plug.     Each plug comes in a velvet bag (color of bag may vary) to keep it safe! All Orders Ship Discreetly! Small Tulip:Insertable length: 2.5 inchesDiameter at widest point: 1.0...
Options Quick look
I Love Cock Butt Plug
I Love Cock Butt Plug
$ 34.99
I love Cock butt plug.  Choose the size of your plug and enjoy the sensation of nice heavy butt plug.     Each plug comes in a velvet bag (color of bag may vary) to keep it safe! All Orders Ship Discreetly! Small Tulip:Insertable length: 2.5 inchesDiameter at widest point: 1.0...
Options Quick look
Custom Nightmare Butt Plug Small Choose Your Image
Custom Nightmare Butt Plug Small Choose Your Image
$ 34.99
New Images available!  Choose the one that works for you.  Each plug comes in a velvet bag (color of bag may vary) to keep it safe!  This listing is for a SMALL plug only.  Want a different size?  Check out the Medium here and the Large here. All Orders Ship Discreetly! Small Tulip:Insertable length:...
Options Quick look
Kinky Minion Butt Plug
Kinky Minion Butt Plug
$ 34.99
Kinky Minion butt plug.  Choose the size of your plug and enjoy the sensation of nice heavy butt plug.     Each plug comes in a velvet bag (color of bag may vary) to keep it safe! All Orders Ship Discreetly! Small Tulip:Insertable length: 2.5 inchesDiameter at widest point: 1.0 inchesMedium Tulip:Insertable...
Options Quick look
Custom Hero Butt Plug Intermediate Choose your Image 11-20
Custom Hero Butt Plug Intermediate Choose your Image 11-20
$ 39.99
Everyone has a favorite hero!  Choose yours and choose the style of your plug.  Insert and increase the sensations during your sexual play!  This item is made to order.  Please allow 1-2 business days for production prior to shipping.  All Orders Ship Discreetly! Style 1: Insertable length: 2.9 inchesDiameter at widest point: 1.3 inches Style...
Options Quick look
Custom Hero Butt Plug Intermediate Choose your Image 1-10
Custom Hero Butt Plug Intermediate Choose your Image 1-10
$ 39.99
Everyone has a favorite hero!  Choose yours and choose the style of your plug.  Insert and increase the sensations during your sexual play!  This item is made to order.  Please allow 1-2 business days for production prior to shipping.  All Orders Ship Discreetly! Style 1: Insertable length: 2.9 inchesDiameter at widest point: 1.3 inchesStyle...
Options Quick look
Custom Clan Butt Plug Small Choose Your Image
Custom Clan Butt Plug Small Choose Your Image
$ 34.99
Choose your clan image!  Don't see the one you want?  Send us your image and we'll add it!  This listing is for a SMALL plug only.  Want a different size?  Check out the Medium here and the Large here.   This item is made to order.  Please allow 1-2 business days for production...
Options Quick look
Custom Wars Butt Plug Choose your Image Medium Butt Plug
Custom Wars Butt Plug Choose your Image Medium Butt Plug
$ 39.99
New Images available!  Choose the one that works for your personality!Each plug comes in a velvet bag (color of bag may vary) to keep it safe!  This listing is for a Medium plug only.  Want a different size?  Check out the Small here and the Large here. All Orders Ship Discreetly! Medium...
Options Quick look
Custom Wars Butt Plug Choose your Image Small Butt Plug
Custom Wars Butt Plug Choose your Image Small Butt Plug
$ 34.99
New Images available!  Choose the one that works for your personality!Each plug comes in a velvet bag (color of bag may vary) to keep it safe!  This listing is for a SMALL plug only.  Want a different size?  Check out the Medium here and the Large here. All Orders Ship...
Options Quick look
Purple Dragon Eye Butt Plug
Purple Dragon Eye Butt Plug
$ 34.99
Purple Dragon Eye butt plug.  Choose the size of your plug and enjoy the sensation of nice heavy butt plug.     Each plug comes in a velvet bag (color of bag may vary) to keep it safe! All Orders Ship Discreetly! Small Tulip:Insertable length: 2.5 inchesDiameter at widest point: 1.0 inchesMedium...
Options Quick look
Red Pokeball Butt Plug
Red Pokeball Butt Plug
$ 34.99
Red Pokeball butt plug.  Choose the size of your plug and enjoy the sensation of nice heavy butt plug.     Each plug comes in a velvet bag (color of bag may vary) to keep it safe! All Orders Ship Discreetly! Small Tulip:Insertable length: 2.5 inchesDiameter at widest point: 1.0 inchesMedium Tulip:Insertable...
Options Quick look
Custom Hero Butt Plug Advanced Choose your Image 1-10
Custom Hero Butt Plug Advanced Choose your Image 1-10
$ 44.99
Everyone has a favorite hero!  Choose yours and choose the style of your plug.  Insert and increase the sensations during your sexual play!  This item is made to order.  Please allow 1-2 business days for production prior to shipping.  All Orders Ship Discreetly! Style 1: Insertable length: 3.1 inchesDiameter at widest point: 1.6 inchesStyle 2:Insertable...
Options Quick look
Custom Hero Butt Plug Small Choose Your Image 21-30
Custom Hero Butt Plug Small Choose Your Image 21-30
$ 34.99
Everyone has a favorite hero.  Choose yours!   This item is made to order.  Please allow 1-2 business days for production prior to shipping.  All Orders Ship Discreetly! Style 1: Insertable length: 2.4 inchesDiameter at widest point: 1.1 inchesStyle 2: Insertable length: 2.4 inchesDiameter at widest point: 1.1 inchesStyle 3:Insertable length: 2.5 inchesDiameter...
Options Quick look
Custom Nightmare Butt Plug Large Choose Your Image
Custom Nightmare Butt Plug Large Choose Your Image
$ 44.99
New Images available!  Choose the one that works for you.  Each plug comes in a velvet bag (color of bag may vary) to keep it safe!  This listing is for a LARGE plug only.  Want a different size?  Check out the Small here and the Medium here. All Orders Ship Discreetly! Large Tulip:Insertable length:3.5 inchesDiameter...
Options Quick look
Custom Thrones Butt Plug Large Choose Your Image
Custom Thrones Butt Plug Large Choose Your Image
$ 44.99
Choose your image, choose the style of your plug.  Insert and increase the sensations during your sexual play!  This item is made to order.  Please allow 1-2 business days for production prior to shipping.  All Orders Ship Discreetly! Style 1: Insertable length: 3.1 inchesDiameter at widest point: 1.6 inchesStyle 2:Insertable length: 3.1 inchesDiameter at widest...
Options Quick look
Custom Wars Butt Plug Choose your Image Large Butt Plug
Custom Wars Butt Plug Choose your Image Large Butt Plug
$ 44.99
New Images available!  Choose the one that works for your personality!Each plug comes in a velvet bag (color of bag may vary) to keep it safe!  This listing is for a LARGE plug only.  Want a different size?  Check out the Small here and the Medium here. All Orders Ship Discreetly! Large Tulip:Insertable...
Options Quick look
Custom Kitty Butt Plug Choose your Image Medium Butt Plug
Custom Kitty Butt Plug Choose your Image Medium Butt Plug
$ 39.99
New Images available!  Choose the one that works for your personality!Each plug comes in a velvet bag (color of bag may vary) to keep it safe!  This listing is for a Medium plug only.  Want a different size?  Check out the Small here and the Large here. All Orders Ship Discreetly! Medium...
Options Quick look
I Love Piss Butt Plug
I Love Piss Butt Plug
$ 34.99
I love Piss butt plug.  Choose the size of your plug and enjoy the sensation of nice heavy butt plug.     Each plug comes in a velvet bag (color of bag may vary) to keep it safe! All Orders Ship Discreetly! Small Tulip:Insertable length: 2.5 inchesDiameter at widest point: 1.0 inchesMedium...
Options Quick look
Daddy's Little Girl Butt Plug
Daddy's Little Girl Butt Plug
$ 34.99
Daddy's Little Girl butt plug.  Choose the size of your plug and enjoy the sensation of nice heavy butt plug.     Each plug comes in a velvet bag (color of bag may vary) to keep it safe! All Orders Ship Discreetly! Small Tulip:Insertable length: 2.5 inchesDiameter at widest point: 1.0 inchesMedium...
Options Quick look
Grumpy Cat Custom Steel Butt Plug Beginner
Grumpy Cat Custom Steel Butt Plug Beginner
$ 34.99
Choose the style of your plug.  Insert and increase the sensations during your sexual play! This item is made to order.  Please allow 1-2 business days for production prior to shipping.  All Orders Ship Discreetly!  Style 1: Insertable length: 2.4 inchesDiameter at widest point: 1.1 inchesStyle 2:Insertable length: 2.4 inchesDiameter at widest point:...
Options Quick look
Custom Thrones Butt Plug Long Choose Your Image
Custom Thrones Butt Plug Long Choose Your Image
$ 49.99
Choose your image, choose the style of your plug.  Insert and increase the sensations during your sexual play!  This item is made to order.  Please allow 1-2 business days for production prior to shipping.  All Orders Ship Discreetly! Style 1: Insertable length: 4.7 inchesDiameter at widest point: 1.2 inchesStyle 2:Insertable length: 4.75 inchesDiameter at widest...
Options Quick look